2005
EAST
First Team (11):
- Michael Brown, Ryle
- Brendon Eager, Highlands
- Logan Hall, Lexington Catholic
- Sean Kelley, Paul Dunbar
- Lucas Koszewski, Lafayette
- Josh Lipka, Lexington Catholic
- Jesse Lokovich, Scott County
- Tim Muessig, Paul Dunbar
- Kevin Murphy, Scott
- Frank Natta, Paul Dunbar
- Jim Uebel, Bishop Brossart
Second Team (11):
- Davis Bates, Frankfort
- Eric Curtis, Boyle County
- Darko Desancic, Scott
- Daniel Fogtman, Lafayette
- Preston Freeman, Ashland Blazer
- Kyle Frimming, Bishop Brossart
- Andy Howard, Lexington Catholic
- Brian Lawless, Paul Dunbar
- Matt Mikhall, Covington Catholic
- Christian Smith, West Jessamine
- D.J. Young, Newport Central Catholic
Honorable Mention (22):
- Toby Anderson, Lafayette
- Zach Appel, Woodford County
- Nick Blank, Newport Central Catholic
- Chris Cahill, Oneida Baptist
- Ralph Compton, Madison Southern
- David Dauer, Paul Dunbar
- John Elrod, Pendleton County
- Kyle Embertson, Paul Dunbar
- Rick Garr, West Jessamine
- Stu Hampson, Henry Clay
- Boston Howe, Grant County
- Will Johnston, Scott County
- J.D. Kepler, Ashland Blazer
- Matt Koppe, Lexington Catholic
- Andrew Moore, South Laurel
- Drew McCaffery, Ashland Blazer
- Glenn Smith, Owen County
- Todd Spears, Highlands
- Jared Techau, Bourbon County
- Clay Turner, Lexington Christian
- Aaron Vossmer, Western Hills
- Brian Williams, Tates Creek
WEST
First Team (11):
- Robert Elliott, Madisonville-North Hopkins
- Alex Encarnacion, Central
- Alex Holmes, Greenwood
- Drew Kapfhammer, Ballard
- Andrew Howard, Owensboro Catholic
- Ross Kaufman, DuPont Manual
- Alex McClure, St. Xavier
– Kennedy Nawka, Atherton
- Zach Sims, Graves County
- Jeff Smith, Daviess County
- Grant Wheeler, Bethlehem
Second Team (11):
- Ben Clayton, Madisonville-North Hopkins
– Dustin Davis, Heath
- Derek Hinson, Marshall County
- Robert Kaebnick, St. Xavier
- James Kusak, Trinity
- Chris Molina, North Hardin
- Adam Pollack, DuPont Manual
- Blake Pruett, Greenwood
- Taylor Ralph, Daviess County
- Gary Smith, Kentucky Country Day
- John Tessandori, Owensboro
Honorable Mention (22):
- Aaron Arndt, Madisonville-North Hopkins
- Joey Bohrman, Marshall County
- Jarod Cooper, Elizabethtown
- Jordan Gass, Greenwood
- Mark Gilliam, Owensboro
- Chris Greenwell, Bethlehem
- Hunter Harris, Daviess County
- Denis Kuljancic, Atherton
- Chase Lester, Christian County
- Connor Link, Elizabethtown
- A.J. Miller, Ballard
- Drew Nowlin, Mayfield
- Danny Pelletier, South Oldham
- Jordan Ross, Ballard
- Phillip Shepherd, Hopkinsville
- Matt Skaff, John Hardin
– Cody Smith, Shelby County
- Will Thompson, Trinity
- Ross Wagner, Paducah Tilghman
- Andrew Warmath, Paducah Tilghman
- Jason White, Madisonville-North Hopkins
- Nick Wilbar, DuPont Manual